FAQ: Questions and Answers

[back to notice text] Question: What can be kept as a trade secret? Answer: A trade secret is information that provides a business with a competitive advantage. The following section provides examples of circumstances where trade secret protection was approved or denied. Courts have provided trade secret protection to formulas, patterns, plans, designs, physical devices, processes, software, and [back to notice text] Question: What do courts consider in determining if a trade secret exists? Answer: Courts usually consider the following three factors in determining whether you have a trade secret: (1) Is the information deemed to be a "trade secret" valuable to the business? Only secret information can be protected by trade secret law. Secrecy is typically determined by evaluating whether or not the information is "generally known" or "readily ascertainable." If the information is secret, you must consider whether the secret information is valuable to your business. How would you rank its value? Courts tend to find that the information is a trade secret if the information is so valuable as to significantly impact the operations of a business. (2) What steps have been taken to keep the information secret? Trade secret laws require that you have taken some action to keep your information a secret. The security procedure taken to protect the information is often the most important evidence that the information constitutes a trade secret. For example, courts have often found that restricting access (on a "need to know" basis) to any sensitive information is a factor that helps to meet this requirement. Courts have also found that physical security, such as keeping written trade secret information in a locked drawer and granting very limited access to it, can meet this requirement. Generally, holders of trade secrets develop a formal system for safeguarding their trade secret information. Such a system can include, for example, reviewing information to be sure that the secret information is not included in documents sent to customers and competitors. In addition, proprietary notices can be placed on all documents containing information related to trade secrets and strict confidentiality provisions can be written into all consulting, manufacturing, employment, and/or non-disclosure agreements. (3) To what extent do employees and others involved in the business know about the information? What about people outside the business? The extent that those in your business and those outside the business have access to the information can affect a court's decision as to whether you have a legal trade secret. Generally, courts have found the information to be public knowledge and not a trade secret if people who do not have a need to know the information have access to it. This is especially true if many people outside the company are familiar with the information. [back to notice text] Question: What is intellectual property? Answer: Intellectual property consists of property created through human creativity. It includes, for example, literature, the visual arts, music, drama, compilations of useful information, computer programs, biotechnology, electronics, mechanics, chemistry, product design, and trade identity symbols. Intellectual property law is designed to promote human creativity without excessively restricting dissemination of the fruits of such creativity. Intellectual property rights are embodied in patents, trade secrets, copyrights, and trademarks. [back to notice text] Question: How can I protect my trade secrets from disclosure by my employees? Answer: There are two types of legal contracts that are widely used to help businesses protect trade secrets: (1) non-disclosure agreements; and (2) non-compete agreements. Often, these agreements are included as part of an "employee agreement' that is signed upon commencement of employment. (1) NON-DISCLOSURE AGREEMENTS (NDAs) During the course of business, you may have to disclose your business secrets to your employees. What happens when you have a disloyal, untrustworthy, or dishonest employee and that employee knows your secrets? Is there anything you can do to stop the employee from telling others? A non-disclosure agreement (NDA) is a confidentiality agreement that can be used to protect trade secrets. Often, during the regular course of business, your secret information may be disclosed to employees or business partners. An NDA requires that the information be kept a secret. The provisions of the agreement require the person to keep the information confidential. If someone has signed an NDA and uses your trade secret without your authorization, you can sue for damages and stop the violator. (2) NON-COMPETE AGREEMENTS During the regular course of business, you may have to disclose your business secrets to your employees. But what happens when these employees leave your company? By requiring your employees to sign a non-compete agreement, employees must agree not to work for a direct competitor for a certain amount of time after leaving your company. The theory behind this type of agreement is that after a certain amount of time, your trade secret will no longer be valuable because of technological changes as your business advances, and, accordingly, the technology will no longer need to be protected as a trade secret. It is important to be aware that courts use a "rule of reason" in deciding whether a noncompete agreement is legal. In other words, the terms of a non-compete agreement must be reasonable as to the duration, territory, and scope of the activity. A restraint is generally enforceable if it is fairly designed to protect the employer [back to notice text] Question: What does ?misappropriating? a trade secret mean? Answer: One has ??misappropriated? a trade secret if he or she has acquired, disclosed, or used the trade secret information without the permission of the holder, where such activities were done through improper means (e.g., the trade secret information was stolen from the holder) or in breach of an obligation of confidentiality or non-use. If you have received a letter stating that you have ?misappropriated? a trade secret (see SAMPLE LETTERS; also see TRADE SECRET LAWS), you should consult with an attorney.

Topic maintained by Santa Clara University School of Law High Tech Law Institute